Is My Tight Pelvic Floor Really the Reason for My Symptoms?

Have you ever been told that your pelvic floor is too tight, and that's why you're experiencing symptoms?

Maybe you've been told you have trigger points, muscle tension or a dysfunctional pelvic floor.

Perhaps you've spent months doing stretches, breathing exercises or having internal treatments to release those muscles.

But the pain keeps coming back.

So what's going on?

In Episode 135 of The Pelvic Floor Project, I sat down with physiotherapist Carolyn Vandyken to challenge some of the common messages surrounding pelvic floor dysfunction and persistent pelvic pain.

Carolyn has been practising physiotherapy for 40 years, with 25 years dedicated to pelvic health. Her work combines musculoskeletal physiotherapy, pain science and a whole-person approach to treatment.

And our conversation raised a question I think we need to ask more often:

What if the pelvic floor isn't the problem, but is responding to the problem?

Are pelvic floors really just tight or weak?

One of the reasons I started this podcast was because I felt we were losing the nuance in healthcare conversations.

Social media is full of simple explanations.

Your pelvic floor is weak? Strengthen it.

Your pelvic floor is tight? Release it.

Your muscles are dysfunctional? Fix them.

But our bodies are so much more complicated than that.

I regularly have patients come into my clinic saying, "I've been told I have a tight pelvic floor."

And I often wonder what that means to them.

Do they think their muscles are permanently shortened?

That something is wrong with their anatomy?

That their pelvic floor is somehow broken?

Because the language we use matters.

I often ask patients to consider the difference between these two statements:

"Your pelvic floor is tight."

And:

"Your pelvic floor seems to be behaving protectively right now."

The first sounds like a diagnosis.

The second suggests that the muscles may be responding to something happening in the body.

And importantly, that response may be able to change.

What if muscle tension is a protective response?

Carolyn made an important point during our conversation.

When someone experiences tenderness during a pelvic floor examination, we often interpret that tenderness as evidence of a muscle problem.

But tenderness doesn't necessarily tell us why the muscle is sensitive.

And it certainly doesn't prove that the muscle is the original cause of someone's pain.

Think about what happens when you're startled.

Your shoulders lift.

Your jaw might clench.

Your abdominal muscles tighten.

And your pelvic floor may contract too.

You didn't consciously decide to tighten those muscles.

Your nervous system did it automatically.

That's because one of the nervous system's jobs is to protect us.

The pelvic floor surrounds areas involved in bladder, bowel and sexual function. It makes sense that these muscles may respond protectively when the nervous system perceives a threat.

Sometimes that response is helpful.

But when pain persists, the nervous system can become increasingly sensitive and protective.

And the muscles may continue to respond even when that level of protection is no longer necessary.

The muscle tension may be part of the pain experience without necessarily being the original cause of it.

Think of your nervous system as a helicopter parent

This is an analogy I often use with patients.

Imagine a helicopter parent watching their child at the playground.

They're constantly scanning for danger.

Don't climb too high.

Be careful.

Watch out.

You might get hurt.

Their intentions are good.

They're trying to protect their child.

But sometimes that protection becomes excessive.

Our nervous system can behave similarly.

Its job is to monitor what's happening in and around our bodies and respond to potential threats.

When it feels safe, we generally move more freely and experience less protective muscle activity.

But when it perceives danger, it may increase muscle guarding, sensitivity and pain.

And here's the interesting part.

The nervous system doesn't respond only to physical injury.

It can also be influenced by stress, poor sleep, previous experiences, beliefs, fear and uncertainty.

This doesn't mean the pain is imaginary or psychological.

It means that pain is an experience created by a complex nervous system that is constantly taking information from the body and the world around us.

Why does my pelvic floor feel different when I'm relaxed?

I often demonstrate this concept with patients during an assessment.

Imagine someone lying on the examination table.

They're nervous.

They've never had an internal pelvic floor examination before.

They don't know what to expect.

And then a stranger is examining a very private part of their body.

Would it really be surprising if their muscles were guarding?

Now imagine that we slow things down.

We talk through what's happening.

They feel more comfortable.

They take a few slower breaths.

Suddenly, the tenderness may decrease.

But what actually changed?

We didn't stretch the muscles.

We didn't release a trigger point.

We didn't fix anything.

We changed the context in which their nervous system was experiencing the examination.

Carolyn described the pelvic floor as almost being a mirror of what's happening in the nervous system.

I love that analogy.

It helps explain why pelvic floor tenderness can fluctuate depending on how someone is feeling, what they've experienced and how safe their body perceives a situation to be.

It also reminds us that a single examination finding doesn't necessarily define someone's pelvic floor function.

Have we blamed the pelvic floor for too much?

Carolyn shared a phrase during our conversation that really stuck with me.

"The pelvic floor has been framed."

What she meant is that we've become so focused on the pelvic floor as the source of symptoms that we sometimes forget to look at everything else.

Someone experiences painful sex.

We look for pelvic floor tension.

Someone has bladder pain.

We look for trigger points.

Someone has persistent pelvic pain.

We try to release the muscles.

But what if the tenderness we're finding is one piece of a much larger picture?

What if the person also experiences migraines, irritable bowel syndrome, low back pain, poor sleep or widespread sensitivity?

What if they've been dealing with persistent stress or have become fearful of movement because of their symptoms?

These factors don't mean the pelvic floor is irrelevant.

They mean we need to consider how the pelvic floor fits into the bigger picture.

The pelvic floor is part of a system. It doesn't function independently from the rest of the body.

Why doesn't releasing the muscles always fix the pain?

This is something I see in clinical practice.

A patient comes in after months, sometimes years, of treatment.

They've had internal manual therapy.

They've stretched.

They've used relaxation techniques.

They may feel better immediately after treatment, but the relief doesn't last.

So they return for another treatment.

And another.

And another.

At some point, I think we need to ask:

What are we missing?

Carolyn shared an example of a patient who had received weekly pelvic floor release treatments for approximately a year.

Despite all that treatment, her symptoms persisted.

When Carolyn began looking more broadly at the person's pain experience, protective responses and other contributing factors, the treatment approach changed.

And the patient improved.

Now, this doesn't mean manual therapy is never helpful.

There are certainly situations where hands-on treatment can provide relief, improve comfort or help someone reconnect with their body.

But if we repeatedly treat the same muscle tenderness without meaningful or lasting improvement, perhaps it's time to reconsider our explanation.

Rather than continually asking how we can release the muscle, we might ask:

Why does this muscle keep responding this way?

What does the rest of your life have to do with pelvic pain?

Quite a lot, potentially.

One of the things Carolyn emphasized was the importance of looking at lifestyle factors when treating persistent pain.

Not because these factors explain every symptom, but because they can influence how sensitive and protective our nervous system becomes.

For example:

  • Sleep: Are you getting enough restorative sleep, or are you constantly exhausted?

  • Stress: Are there ongoing demands in your life that leave you feeling overwhelmed?

  • Movement: Are you physically active, or have pain and fear gradually reduced what you're doing?

  • Strength: Are you maintaining muscle strength and physical capacity?

  • Nutrition: Are you eating regularly and adequately to support your health?

  • Relaxation: Do you have opportunities to feel calm, safe and comfortable in your body?

Sometimes these conversations surprise patients.

They've come to see me about their pelvic floor.

Why am I asking about sleep?

Why do I care about their exercise habits?

Why am I interested in their stress levels?

Because these things are connected.

For someone experiencing persistent pelvic pain, improving sleep, building physical activity or finding strategies to manage stress may help reduce their overall symptom burden.

And sometimes those changes have a greater impact than another set of pelvic floor stretches.

Of course, lifestyle changes aren't a cure for every type of pelvic pain, and they shouldn't replace investigation or treatment of underlying medical conditions.

But they're important pieces of the puzzle that we sometimes overlook.

What about the different types of pain?

Carolyn also discussed something that I think is particularly important for healthcare professionals.

Not all pain works the same way.

Pain is commonly described using three mechanisms.

Nociceptive pain occurs when the nervous system responds to actual or threatened damage to non-neural tissues. An acute muscle strain is one example.

Neuropathic pain is caused by a lesion or disease affecting the somatosensory nervous system.

Nociplastic pain describes pain arising from altered pain processing when there isn't clear evidence that tissue damage or a nerve lesion adequately explains the pain.

These mechanisms can overlap.

And identifying which mechanisms may be contributing can help guide treatment.

For example, someone with persistent pelvic pain, widespread sensitivity and multiple overlapping pain conditions may benefit from a very different approach than someone with a recent, localized tissue injury.

The important thing is that we shouldn't assume every person with pelvic pain has the same problem.

And we certainly shouldn't assume that tenderness in the pelvic floor automatically means those muscles are causing the pain.

The words we use can influence recovery

This was one of my favourite parts of our conversation.

As healthcare professionals, we need to be mindful of the messages patients take away from their appointments.

Imagine being told:

Your pelvic floor is extremely tight.

Your muscles aren't functioning properly.

Your pelvis is out of alignment.

Your core isn't activating.

Even when these statements are intended to be helpful, they can leave someone feeling that their body is fragile or dysfunctional.

And when someone already has pain, those beliefs may influence how they move and interpret sensations.

They may become afraid of exercise.

They may constantly monitor their pelvic floor.

They may believe they need someone to release or correct their muscles before they can function normally.

I think we need to be careful not to unintentionally create that dependence.

Instead, what if we explained that the body can become protective?

That pain can change?

That muscle activity and sensitivity are influenced by many factors?

And that there are often several ways to help someone regain comfort and confidence?

The goal should be to help people understand their bodies, not leave them feeling afraid of them.

What should pelvic health physiotherapy look like?

If you're experiencing persistent pelvic pain, I would encourage you to look for a healthcare professional who takes the time to understand your whole experience.

Not just where it hurts.

Not just what your pelvic floor feels like during an examination.

But how your symptoms affect your life.

A good assessment might explore your bladder and bowel symptoms, sexual health, physical activity, sleep, stress, medical history and previous treatment experiences.

It should also consider your goals.

What do you want to get back to doing?

What have you stopped doing because of pain?

What do you think is contributing to your symptoms?

What would you like help with first?

Carolyn also emphasized the importance of asking permission before introducing a different explanation for someone's symptoms.

I think this is so important.

People don't arrive in our clinics as blank slates.

They've often been given diagnoses, explanations and treatment plans by other healthcare professionals.

They may have spent years believing that their pelvic floor is the problem.

Rather than simply telling them that everything they've previously heard is wrong, we can invite them to consider another possibility.

What if we looked at this a little differently?

Would you be open to exploring some other factors that might be contributing?

And then we can work together to find a starting point that makes sense to them.

What if you've tried everything and you're still in pain?

First, I would encourage you not to interpret unsuccessful treatment as evidence that your body can't improve.

Sometimes the treatment simply hasn't addressed the factors that are most relevant to your symptoms.

If you've spent months focusing on releasing your pelvic floor without lasting improvement, it may be worth exploring a broader approach.

That could involve physiotherapy, medical assessment, pain education, gradual exercise, psychological support, sleep strategies or other interventions depending on your situation.

It doesn't mean you need to change everything about your life overnight.

And it certainly doesn't mean your pain is your fault because you're stressed or not sleeping well.

It means there may be other opportunities to support your recovery.

One thing Carolyn said that I particularly appreciated was that she tries to identify opportunities rather than problems.

Instead of presenting someone with a long list of everything that's wrong, she looks for areas where meaningful change might be possible.

And then she asks the patient where they'd like to start.

I think that's a much more empowering approach.

The takeaway: Look beyond the muscles

I hope this conversation encourages both patients and healthcare professionals to question some of the language we've become accustomed to using in pelvic health.

A tender pelvic floor isn't necessarily a damaged pelvic floor.

Muscle guarding isn't always the cause of pain.

And persistent symptoms don't automatically mean there's something structurally wrong that needs to be released or fixed.

Sometimes the pelvic floor is responding to a nervous system that's become protective.

Sometimes there are several contributing factors.

And sometimes we need to look beyond the muscles themselves to understand why symptoms persist.

Rather than asking only, "How do I release my tight pelvic floor?" perhaps we should also be asking, "Why might my pelvic floor be protecting me in the first place?"

That question can open the door to a much broader and more individualized approach to recovery.



This blog is intended for educational purposes only and does not replace individualized medical advice.

About Carolyn Vandyken

Carolyn Vandyken is a physiotherapist, educator, and author with 40 years of clinical experience in orthopaedics, pelvic health, and persistent pain. A founding director of Reframe Rehab and co-founder of Pelvic Health Solutions, she teaches internationally, integrating pain science and a whole-person approach into physiotherapy practice.

Carolyn has co-authored peer-reviewed research, textbook chapters, and the patient education book Why Pelvic Pain Hurts. Her work bridges research, clinical care, and education to support a broader understanding of pelvic health and pain. She received the Ontario Physiotherapy Association’s Education Award in 2015 and the Canadian Physiotherapy Association’s Medal of Distinction in 2021.


Episode Partners

This episode of The Pelvic Floor Project is supported by Embodia and SRC Health, organizations that help make it possible for me to continue creating evidence-based pelvic health education.

Embodia provides online continuing education and mentorship for pelvic health and rehabilitation professionals, including access to courses and expert-led learning from clinicians around the world.

SRC Health creates medical compression garments designed to provide support during pregnancy, postpartum recovery and for women experiencing pelvic health concerns.

Sponsorship does not influence the topics, guests or educational content of The Pelvic Floor Project.

Next
Next

5 Things I Wish Every Postpartum Woman Knew About Recovery